What if, subtitled the world's foremost military historians imagine what might have been, is a collection of twenty essays and thirteen sidebars dealing with counterfactual history it was published by gp putnam's sons in 1999, isbn 0-399-14576-1 , and this book as well as its two sequels , what if 2 and what ifs of american history , were edited by robert cowley. Counterfactual history, also sometimes referred to as virtual history, is a form of historiography that attempts to answer what if questions known as counterfactuals.
Counterfactual history done in such broad strokes ‘allows historians to rewrite history according to their present-day purposes and prejudices’ evans’ explanation for the imaginative turn to counterfactualism since 1990 is that several social, political and cultural changes came together.
A point made in the third of these essays, on the value of history, was the widespread human enjoyment of a good story it was suggested that history played a part in satisfying this need the consistent success of fiction based on a simple form of counterfactual history — robert harris's fatherland is a good recent example — seems to indicate that this type of history is equally appealing.
The closer the counterfactual can hew to actual historical possibility, the more plausible it can be judged to be the end result should be a counterfactual that is relatively close to the given historical record, and offers a new way to think about the period under discussion. Philosophy of history, counterfactual history, historiography and philosophy of history a counterfactual study of the charge of the light brigade researchers use a mathematical model to perform a counterfactual study of the 1854 charge of the light brigade.
The experience of regret arguably relies on a multifaceted, counterfactual analysis of two previously possible outcomes an important question to consider is at what age these counterfactual emotions develop, and what enables these responses to occur we will write a custom essay sample on counterfactual thinking specifically for you for. In “straight” history, and by extension, truth, history expounds on the straightforward claims in general counterfactual claims would leave no evidence, no straightforward trails to grow any claims, and by being in nature untrue, counterfactual claims can be disregarded from a serious argument with no more attention served to them.
Pathways (essays) neil munro counterfactualism in history a point made in the third of these essays, on the value of history, was the widespread human enjoyment of a good story it was suggested that history played a part in satisfying this need.
Counterfactual history has intrigued and confounded philosophers, social scientists, and some distinguished historians as well psychologists focus on “hindsight bias”—the judgment that.